Lately I've been doing a ton of reading on pedaling, pedal strokes, foot position, knee position, crank lengths and blah blah blah. I'm still having some issues with my left knee (it was both knees but is now isolated to my left knee). I've check my seat height, fore/aft knee position relative to the pedal axel, I'm using pedals with a ton of float, more spinning less mashing but still a little pain.
During my research I came across this article by Grant of Rivendale Bicycle Works about "
the Shoe Ruse". The article was more about the benefits of pedaling with flat pedals (or platform pedals) and really had nothing to do with knee pain. Never the less I found his article intriguing, his focus was mainly centered on how you can use just about any shoe you like (including Hush Puppies) with a $20 pedal to get the same amount of performance you would get using a clipless pedal system. He also went on to explain how all the benefits of clipless pedals are not true.
WHA! WHA! WHAT?!?!?
But with clipless pedals you can get a 360º pedal stroke!
And your feet won't spontaneously fly into the spokes! And you don't actually have to think about keeping your feet on the pedals! And when I'm connected to the bike I transfer all my power! What about "correct" feet placement?!?! You mean people actually ride their bikes and survive without clipless pedals and special cycling shoes?!?!?! That's gotta be Bullshit!
To backup his outrageous claims he also mentions some studies where researchers measured the downward pressure that Professional cyclist put on clipless pedals and the upward pressure on the back stroke (or upstroke). They also used the same test to measure recreational riders. During these studies they concluded that even the pros don't really use the back stroke to increases their power but they do gain a modest amount of efficiency by unloading the opposite pedal to limit the resistance. They are not getting a 360º pedal stroke as promoted by clipless pedal makers. For untrained recreational riders, they only apply downward pressure.
That can't be true, he must have made that crap up!
Since Grant didn't put any references in his article I hit PubMed to find the supporting research. You wouldn't believe the amount of studies that's been done around cycling and pedaling. I found about 1000 related papers, including the study that supports Grant's article. I sent about 17 links to my buddy at Stanford to download for me, I will post some more on that in the future.
I have to admit this isn't the first time I've heard about this study but because I was happy with my setup I never paid it much attention. I've been riding clipless pedals since I was 16 years old, I've never really looked at anything else. My original motivation for going with them was a friend (who was a sponsored rider) gave me a pair to try. I was 16 and wanted to be cool like the pros so I put them on and went through the initiation process (lots of falling while attached to the bike when stopped).
I've never question that decision or my beliefs about clipless pedals till now. When I look at all the
benefits of clipless pedals (safety over bumps, perceived biomechanics efficacy, no feet in my spokes... etc) I think back to all those years before I used clipless pedals. Especially when I was a kid riding my BMX bike over and off everything I could find. I don't remember having issue of my feet spontaneously flying off the pedals or thinking there has to be a better way.
With all this in mind, I decided to do a little experiment to see if I can be happy with platform pedals and regular shoes. Plus, I'm getting to the end of life with my current pair of shoes, the inside heal in my left shoe is worn out to the point that it's time to replace them. If you've ever shopped for decent cycling shoe you know they are not cheap, $80 - $220 a pair!
This weekend I stopped by Sports Basement and picked up a pair of $20 Odyssey platform pedals with some really good traction. I installed these pedals yesterday and tried them out with my Puma's, they feel amazingly solid. My plan is to give this an honest chance by riding for the next 4 weeks using the platform pedals. I'm going to ride all my normal routes including the mixed terrain rambles just to make sure I cover all my use cases. To be more scientific I will compare my ride reports from previous rides (w/clipless pedals) to my rides (w/platform pedals).
On Oct 13, I will make a decision to either keep these pedals on my bike and officially switch over or install them on Amanda's bike since I sold her pedals with my Schwinn Road Bike (sorry baby, he didn't want clipless pedals... go figure!) I will either be liberated from the clipless-pedal-cycling-shoe-strangle-hold or I will put this clipless-pedals-are-not-better crap to rest once and for all.
If your lucky, You might even see me riding around with flip flops and thick wool socks in a full roadie kit. Just imagine the looks I will get from people as I pass them in that outfit!